It can be tough to find time to integrate arts into an already overstuffed curriculum. So today I’ve invited an experienced elementary and middle school art teacher, Jenny Knappenberger of Art with Jenny K, to share one of her favorite ways to get kids creating and collaborating. Thank you, Jenny!

Teaching students with an art-infused curriculum is a sure-fire way to get students engaged and involved in their learning. We teachers are pretty savvy to this by now…witness the wide variety of art-infused offerings on websites like Teachers Pay Teachers and Pinterest. Administrators and curriculum writers know curriculum material but classroom teachers know kids ….and teachers know that kids like to “do” in order to learn. (If only they would listen to us, right?!).


Integrating the arts helps children solve problems, think creatively and critically, and to express themselves as individuals. Have you ever thought about how useful art integration can also be for fostering collaboration in your classroom?

Here is an example from my classroom.

Brown Bag Art Challenge

I designed a lesson called “Brown Bag Art Challenge” to challenge my students to create something while collaborating. Students were put into groups of about four kids. I even tried to pair up unlikely kids to let them work together–no BFFs! I gave each group a brown lunch bag with a “challenge” written on a paper that I put inside (the presentation of the challenge in the brown bag increased the students curiosity and established a lesson name that the students became familiar with).

In the bags were different challenges. Each group was asked to solve the challenge they were given using a variety of supplies I provided. If you have a large group of kids (I know–so sorry–of course you do!) it’s okay to give two groups the same challenge. It’s great for kids to see how different groups solve the same challenges.


I set up a table at the front of the room that was full of miscellaneous art supplies like paper, rulers, scissors, tape, glue, markers, crayons and pencils. I did NOT put the supplies in the bags because I wanted students to decide which supplies they would need to complete their challenge. This is all about the kids –they have to read the challenge as a group, decide what they think it means and then choose the supplies that they want to use.

Let me show you the challenges I gave my students and you can see some of the pictures I took while they were creating.

Challenge #1: Using the supplies of your choice, make the longest line possible.


Challenge #2: Using the supplies of your choice, create the strongest bridge. Test it with several items such as a pencil, roll of tape, and other items you find around the room to be sure it is strong.


Challenge #3: Using the supplies of your choice, create the tallest standing tower. It has to be able to stand up on its own.

Challenge #4: Using the supplies of your choice, design a house that has 5 windows and 3 doors. The windows and doors must be able to open and close.


Kids will always add their own touch to things… like the kids who put the set of stairs inside of their house. The idea behind this challenge is to let the kids come up with the solutions and let them experience the process of solving a problem (challenge) that is given to them while working together as a team. It’s hard work but they can do it.

Redirect and reassure

Some students will get stuck and many might feel frustrated by the “open endedness” of this project–and that is the point…so don’t do the thinking for them. Redirect them to their group to help them solve the problems and reassure them that they can do it! Let them be frustrated if they need to… it’s okay. This isn’t about the end result, it’s about the way they work together and think through a problem, all while seeing it through to completion. Kids have such great ideas and this lesson will show them that we trust their judgemetn and decision making abilities.

Inevitably groups finish at different times. I have individual students fill out this form when their group is done. Students enjoy reflecting on their work on this form and it’s a great place for students to feel like their individual voice is heard in the group setting.


So my challenge to you, the educator, is to try this lesson with your kids and watch in amazement as they solve these fun problems.

I have created this lesson in a pdf file as a FREE lesson for the readers of the Cornerstone blog. You can download it by clicking on the image below. Included are all of the steps, handouts and examples I have shared with you in this post. There are blank sheets that you can use to add your own challenge–mix it up depending on the grade level you teach. You can get started right away!


Than you for reading and for making art with your students!

Jenny K.

art-with-jenny-k-round-logo1-125x125Jenny Knappenberger is an award-winning educator who has taught art to middle school, elementary and gifted children in Virginia and in Arizona. Jenny is also a professional ballroom dancer and instructed for over 8 years in Virginia before committing full-time as an art teacher in Arizona. Her favorite little artist is her 2-year-old daughter who gets to try out mommy’s never-ending list of ideas! Jenny is the owner of “Art with Jenny K.” and is dedicated to making art integration easy and exciting for classroom teachers and is the author of




  1. Sally

    Integrating the arts is essential! Thanks for this great post. The brown bag challenge is a great end of the year activity when the kids just can’t focus on much of anything, but still need to be involved in learning activities. It’s also great for the beginning of the year, when the children need to learn to work as a team. Thanks for sharing!

    • Angela Watson

      I appreciate your comment, Sally! I agree–this is perfect for after standardized testing and end-of-year wrap up.

  2. Melissa – I just blogged about your fun project we did at the end of the school year. Students begged me to do it again AND suggested other challenge ideas, such as to build a national monument or design the biggest free-standing number.

    • Angela Watson

      Awesome! So glad you shared that!

  3. STEM Activities for kids: Imaginary playgrounds - Art with Jenny K.

    […] If you are looking for other fun STEM activities for your children (or STEAM) check out my brown bag art challenge lesson that is available for free on The Cornerstone website HERE. […]

  4. Wayne Widdowson

    Thanks for a great resource. We are kicking off a unit on bullying and making our school a safer place and this fits in nicely with a team building activity I am taking.

  5. Kristen

    Perfect for the week before Winter Break when you don’t want to start a new major project that they will forget but still want them to learn and be engaged!

  6. 5 Ways to Make Art on the First Day of School - The Art of Ed

    […] Get kids collaborating with the Brown Bag Art Challenge […]

  7. Valerie Shears

    I’m an art teacher and I think I will use this as an introduction to the opening of the 3D /Sculpture Center with my 3 and 4 th grades and then go into a skills lesson on attachments and let them have at it for the year!

  8. 2017 Summer Instruction Camp | My So Called Librarian Life

    […] We also had a bit of fun tapping into our teamwork skills with the paper chain game and creative play with our library themed version of the paper bag challenge. […]

  9. A STEAM Activity to Inspire | Famous Faces of STEAM Collaborative Poster - Art with Jenny K

    […] STEM Brown Bag Art Challenge (2nd-6th) […]

  10. 5 Ways to Make Art on the First Day of School - The Art of Education University

    […] Get kids collaborating with the Brown Bag Art Challenge […]

Post a Comment

Want to join the discussion? Feel free to contribute!